Cleavage vs. random breakage Cleavage repeats at the same angles across multiple breaks. Random breakage does not repeat consistently.
Cleavage vs. a flat cut surface Saw marks can look like cleavage. Fresh natural breaks are the reliable indicator.
Cleavage vs. bedding surfaces in the host rock Bedding is a rock-layer surface. Cleavage is inside the mineral and repeats in the grain or crystal.
Cleavage vs. joint faces Joints are fractures in rock units. Cleavage is a mineral property and shows up on repeated mineral breaks.